A continuation of the exquisite solution of the mind/brain problem, begun in the preceeding entry. So far, no comments/arguments/rants yet. Come ON!!
At a friend's birthday recently, I became involved in an extended discussion of whether zombies walk with their hands held out in front of them, or at their sides, awkwardly. I forget which view prevailed. I remember that we all were aware that we were talking about zombies as if they were known entities, and that one of us might encounter a zombie some time in the next few days, and the issue would be settled.
It made me think of an observation common among hypnotists: If you ask young children what somebody who is hypnotized does, they immediately put their arms straight out in front (zombie style??) close their eyes and walk very slowly, but elegantly -- unlike zombies, who, we all know, are clumsy. This knowledge of how hypnotized people behave seems to be acquired mainly from cartoons; there are probably other sources, hard to identify.
The tricky thing is, when the kids are "doing" hypnotized, their minds are doing hypnotized, too -- their thoughts get concrete, they are compliant, they lost any sense of humor, and so on.
Alert Reader will quickly connect to my previous post. Hypnosis is an ongoing interaction between the subject and the ...well, hypnotizer. This conversation constitutes the "mind" of the subject. Again, a transaction that is normative to the construction of experience.
You get the point. Computational and narrative models of the mind are wrong-headed; mind is a kind of talk, a set of directions which structure how to be in the world. Hey, just like I said last time. Alva Noe is working on too small a scale, but Noe is a biological type, and I am an ordinary language type.
Complexity trumps reductionism, every time. The brain is more than the sum of it's cells. Mind, who knows? Mind is more than the sum of a person's interactions We do bring to the table other parts of us. Eyes, noses, emotions. Whoa, there ....emotions?? How about choices? What are we talking about, anyhow???
More to come. A work in progress.
skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Blog entries by month
Pages
Followers
About Me
Popular Posts
-
When I was 21, there was a death in the family, and then the wake. All that day, and at that wake, I was in a strange state. When I walke...
-
The item on the radio: Corporate profits are at an all-time high, worker productivity is at an all-time high, unemployment is still horribl...
-
Maybe ten years ago, maybe more, there was a terrible gas explosion in a home in my town. The house was destroyed; the owners were outside...
-
What if it all goes the way I expect? Total, absolute isolation from the rest of the world, Muslim countries attacking us (which we will ju...
-
It took a long time. A generation of politicians, economists, think-tankers, all the powers-that-be, have been totally, wildly wrong, stupid...
-
If we all became vegans, there would be an agricultural crash; it would last just long enough for all the meat interests, corporate and fami...
-
The Master (ok, Freud) used the amoeba as a metaphor for illness and depression. In normal times, the amoeba moves by extending a part of it...
-
During the French and Indian War, starting around 1708, bounties were offered for the scalps of Native Americans. Each side paid for the sca...
-
We are at the start of the third major brush between Christians and Muslims. Arab Muslims are quite open about loathing the presence of Chri...
-
Way many years ago, I spent most of a year thinking about what happens when we ask questions about people's actions. It was, after all,...
No comments:
Post a Comment